Lead Image

When winning is a lie

Print print Email email Share Share


Like success, which is said to be everyone’s child, any soccer success in a world-class tournament is a moment of wild celebration in Nigeria. And this was the mood Nigerians were thrown into by the achievement of our national team in the just concluded Under 17 FIFA World Cup tournament. Amidst the many problems bedevilling the nation, our performance up to the runner up prize has enlivened this gloomy land provided, some consolation and the usual national solidarity engendered by soccer.

However, beyond the celebrations it cannot be said with every sense of conviction that our success was a well-deserved one. The reason: there was overwhelming evidence that our national team, the Golden Eaglets, fielded players who were well older than the stipulated 17 years. The revelation of this embarrassing scandal came in a trail of insalubrious episodes that threatened to mar the tournament. First, it was contractor problems, and later it became one of lack of funds, and non-accreditation of registered journalists, among others. When it was thought that a release of N3 billion by the federal government would put an end to all these problems,

Colombian coach Ramiro Viafara raised the alarm on over aged players in the tournament. Thereafter, a surge of claims attesting to the presence of over aged players in the team flew from every angle. But it was former Eagles international and lawyer, Mr. Adokiye Amiesimaka, whose vociferous criticism lent credence to the speculations, after the Golden Eaglets whitewashed New Zealand 5-0. In his weekly column in a national newspaper, two weeks ago, Amiesimaka had alleged that the U-17 team captain Fortune Chukwudi was well over 17, stating that the fellow played for him seven years ago in his feeder team as an 18 year old.

In another instance, while affirming “there was no second MRI test on the players”, he indicted top officials of the National Football Federation for wilfully barring the Eaglets from taking part in a second MRI test. The truth of the matter is that when the world football body, FIFA, conceived of this U17 World Cup tournament, it had a youth development programme that would ensure succession management of the game. Ordinarily, this is a tournament that should feature secondary school students and not league players. By fielding over age players our nation team has defeated that purpose, and by laying claim to victory the team is living a lie. Some have preferred to ignore these niceties about morality and values in soccer.

Many Nigerians have posited that football is an amoral issue; others have argued that the act of cheating in tournaments is a global phenomenon, and so in the name of patriotism our case should be overlooked. But then this is a spurious argument lacking every sense of sound judgement. How can we tell good from bad, if we appeal to such self-serving arguments?

The gravity of this simple soccer scenario resonates beyond the issue of sport. If our criticism of graft, maladministration, political ineptitude is to have moral weight, if we claim to have a moral right to condemn public officers who loot state coffers and pillage our economy, we must condemn cheating and lying footballers who fake their age and bribe coaches to get placement on a team. For any reason whatever, this act is a national embarrassment and a shameful one.

It is a dishonourable and ignoble act. Our U17 national team may be called the Golden Eaglets, they may have been awarded the trophy as second place winners, but by this despicable act of officially sanctioned mendacity, and impenitent resolve to argue ad absurdum, our soccer house has demonstrated that it is nowhere near gold. This is not a team to be proud of.

The stain on one finger has spread to all.

Back
Dear Reader.
While we value your feedback we may block inappropriate comment. Please feel free to respond to new comments. Note also that 234NEXT bears no responsibility for what readers post and is not liable for any form of impersonation.

Reader Comments (18)


Posted by chaichow on Nov 16 2009

u av said it all, i whip for the young lads who could av originaly being discovered.they will fall down and die sumday these nfa officials.

Posted by TATA on Nov 16 2009

"...dishonourable and ignoble act"...i thought that was our national credo...

Posted by Tade Ipadeola on Nov 16 2009

True. Never has an editorial on sports been closer to the appropriate metaphor for our nation.

Posted by Gbenga on Nov 16 2009

... whats really sad is that it will be repeated again and again. we've been doing this overage thing from inception of the tournament in china...really sad.

Posted by Ade on Nov 16 2009

We shouldn't always blame leadership corruption as the source of corruption and fraudulent practices in Nigeria. Grassroot corruption is also a source and similarly potent scourge to our reputation and progress. For instance, how come our boys, who knew they were over-age and thus not qualified for the tournament, decline invitation to take part? We can change Nigeria bottom-up if individuals begin to take their stand against what they know to be wrong and damaging to their own reputation, family and that of Nigeria. It is not right and sensible to condemn others of an offence or criminality of which you are equally guilty. That is hypocrisy; and even God hates it.

Posted by igwe czar on Nov 16 2009

If we had won you guys won't be talking this rubbish would you? now you claim they are over aged.

Posted by Peter Osamgbi on Nov 16 2009

The tragedy is that this national embarrassment is coming at a time we are making so much noise about rebranding- changing our old way of life (fraud, cheating, deceit). That the Nigerian leadership is mum on this makes it all the more worse. Sadly, we failed in seizing this opportunity when the world focused on us during the world cup to actually demonstrate that we've changed. Ordinarily, heads should roll; but I do not expect even a single querry.

Posted by daniel on Nov 16 2009

The real sadness is the way most nigerians rejoiced EVEN when they all knew that we CHEATED! The fact we were not caught does not mean it is right! And as the editorial points out this ethos or culture of corruption is now prevalent all over our dear land. Next please continue to report ALL AND ANY BAD story. Rather than you shutting up,its better they change their corrupt attitudes and practise so you will only have good news to write.

Posted by TATA on Nov 16 2009

@igwe czar..is that so? i think you should start attending the synagogue of tb joshua who prophesied a win, for deliverance....

Posted by Johnbosco Chienye on Nov 16 2009

What is sad but not surprising is that most Nigerians who have commented on this article bought the allegation. Their insinuation was that Nigeria can field any player they want without going through the process employed by FIFA(MRI test) to weed-out older players. Any player you saw in our squad is cleared by FIFA, and is eligible to play. Drug use in sports is widespread; some of them were being encouraged by their coaches/managers. When they get caught, do you indict their country? Of course, no! People, it's not just about our government - it's also about you. How good a Nigerian are you? How good are you as a citizen of the world?

Posted by George Uriesi on Nov 16 2009

The tragedy is that so many Nigerians chose to condemn Amiesimeka and to condone this wanton fraud for misplaced patriotic reasons. If we cannot even agree on glaring wrongs, what's the point? We were intent on conniving as a country to cheat our way to a youth tournament 'championship'. And we intended to proudly receive the trophy, had we won it? What a shame...

Posted by Tade Ipadeola on Nov 16 2009

The Honourable Adokiye Amiesimeka did what most elders in this country dont do. He told the truth. That is the only thing worthy of celebration in this whole episode

Posted by Jerry Sawyerr on Nov 16 2009

I have a problem here. Not with players who claim to be younger than their age, but with everyone of us, including the writer of this editorial. The question I have for him(her) is - how many times has this writer paid bribe to the police or LASTMA officials when caught in a traffic offence? How many times has he paid more than the stipulated amount to get his international passport renewed in three days instead of one month if he had played by the rules? How many times has he used his position as a journalist to his advantage and to the detriment of others? How many times has he jumped the queue to get something done on time? I can go on and on. Listen, I don't support cheating players, but I say, we're all guilty as charged.

Posted by sewetronica on Nov 17 2009

Mr Jerry Sawyerr, yes, none is guitiless...all have sinned. The problem with our country is that we are all compromised: leadership and the masses alike. The leaders steal big...the followers dream of stealing big. These so-called 'corrupt' leaders are our fathers, our aunties and our in-laws. In fact the osmosis of corruption is so strong and stiffling, it is effectively illogical not to be a little 'corrupt' in Nigeria : whether it is in giving the obligatory 20 naira notes so the police can leave you be to arrive punctual at a meeting or 'showing gratitude' after a successful business bid: it's all corruption...no need to rationalize it. Still, that is beside the point. It's like scolding your kid for his low school grades and then he retorts by saying he wasn't last in class! Whether the writer of this column (or indeed my very self) has somewhat aided and abetted falsehood sometime ago cannot be the reason Nigeria fields over-aged players...blame should be placed squarely where it should and firmly, too. America and other thriving countries worthy of some study for a number of admirable things are not populated by saints, yet, despite the imperfection, still forge ahead through the rule of law to create some sort of equitable society. It is even ironical that we are a deeply religious country and glory in extravagant acts of zealotry to prove we worship God: pray tell...how do you obey the laws of God who isn't visible and flagrantly flout those of the society that's visible? Nigeria is an Augean stable surely (and by a mile)and it will take some extraordinary effort to create some order in the existentialist chaos that abides and abounds. But all it takes is dividing the work of building amongst many hands.We do not need a crowd to change Nigeria but determined, ready-to-toil apostles of positive change with a definite plan and a strong conviction to talk the talk and walk the walk, leaders and masses alike. Soon, more hands will join. We are all guilty but we cannot fester in our guilt and in the past. Tomorrow starts today. As the country cries desperately for a change, we shouldn't fold our arms and ask 'Why?'. We should fold up our sleeves and reply: 'Why not?'

Posted by Aurora on Nov 17 2009

Over-age players benefit from an unfair advantage due to their greater physical maturity compared to players of the proper age. Cheating, in this manner, isn't only bad for Nigerian football, it is pervasively bad for our society as a whole. Leading up to the finals, the example being set by this saga for all young Nigerians was: deceive, cheat, obscure and you will prosper. So, I am refreshingly glad that we did not win the U-17 FIFA World Cup tournament. It would have disastrously degraded our moral compass even further. Sadly, Nigerians tend to forget so easily. I never cease to be amazed at how shallow our memories are. In four years time, we wil be sneaking over-age players into this U-17 tournament again.

Posted by Gabriel Adewole on Nov 19 2009

The word corruption may soon be dropped from the Edition of the English Dictionaries being used in Nigeria, except of course if the meaning could be modified. The sad reality is that the ordinary man (and woman) on the street does not believe there is anything bad in pocket linnig if you are where it is possible, exam fraud if you have the fee, fake products if someone would buy it, give a wrong personal information if that is the way to scale the huddle. It is sad indeed. Someone said Adokyie would not have spoken up if he had been a member of the LOC or some other committee. Nigerians use any form of line at all to rubbish the few who think it is improper to remain as we have always been.

Posted by Yemmih from UK on Nov 20 2009

I watched the tournament and I was happy that Nigeria didn't win it. It is a general consensus here that Nigerians lie about their true age. Ahgahowa was a typical example of why is not worth it at the end.....as at the time he was playing for Wigan he was over 30 years old and he claimed he was 20 something. He just didn’t click at Wigan and they had to let him go. I know we have quality suitable under 17 boys that will do us proud but i guess they have missed their opportunity. Guys like Fabregas, Messi, Iniesta, Ronaldo etc were given the opportunity that is why they have developed into superstars now. When are we ever going to learn............anyway am happy for the Super Eagles and I don’t think Amodu is technically trained to lead us anywhere? We only qualified bcos of the individual brilliance of the boys.



post a comment

Your name: *



* = Required information