Lead Image

She loved to sing. Now she’s gone, the music has stopped. Photo: COURTESY OF THE ARULOGUNS

Defendants fail to appear in court over 11-year-old girl's death

Print print Email email Share Share


Yesterday, at the Federal High Court in Abeokuta, neither the Faith Academy in Otta, Ogun State and the 16 other defendants, nor their counsels showed up to defend themselves on charges of complicity in the death of 11-year-old Morenike Arulogun, who died of cerebral malaria in 2008.

The sitting Judge, B. I. Molokwu, was surprised that no member of the defence party was present for the hearing of the preliminary objection they had submitted to the court in late September, 2009. She adjourned the case to allow for another notice of hearing to be served the defendants. "We will give them time to appear.

The defendants will be served with fresh notices. I am doing this because I don't want anyone to accuse me of not giving them fair hearing. The case is adjourned to Friday, October 30, 2009," the judge said.

The counsel to the plaintiff, Oluyinka Oyeniji of Banwo, Adeyemo and Igbokwe Chambers was also surprised that Faith Academy and its lawyers would feel no obligation to show up in a case involving the demise of an ex-student of Faith Academy. "It is surprising that a counsel can choose to come or not at will. And this to me shows the levity they [Faith Academy] have been taking the death of Morenike, whose death was occasioned by their poor health management.

Let's hope they'll treat the court with more respect," he said. Mr. Oyeniji said he was further surprised because last week on October 7, 2009, he had submitted to the Federal High Court his chamber's counter-affidavit to the preliminary objections of the defendants, which he said was acknowledged by the defendants counsel.

When NEXT contacted Ogochukwu Mbamalu of Jumbo Chambers, the counsel to Faith Academy and eight other defendants mentioned in the law suit No. FHC/AB/CS/58/09, he said he was never notified when the case was coming up. "Yes, they served us their counter-affidavit on the 7th but we were not given any hearing notice. The Federal High Court should have given us notice but they did not. We've just been informed of the new date and we will be there," Mr. Mbamalu said. For Toye and Idorenyin Arulogun, who were both present at the court, their cause is a justified one, which they say they have thought over ever since their daughter Morenike passed away on November 21, 2008. "It is a very traumatic experience we are going through.

Morenike loved to sing but now there is no more music in our family. We don't wish anyone goes through what we are facing and that is why we are creating awareness on the Movement Against Negligence In Boarding Schools (MANIBS)," Mrs. Arulogun said. "(The movement's) aim is to get schools and regulatory bodies like the Ministries of Education and Health to establish the procedures schools should follow in the management of students in their trust.

Many people have suffered this kind of negligence and it is time we spoke out against this," Mrs. Arulogun added.

Back
Dear reader.
While we value your feedback we have to moderate them, so your comments would appear in a maximum of one hour. Please feel free to return and read through again after another user may have replied to what you have said.
Please note that 234NEXT.com bears no responsibility for what readers post, and is not liable for any form of impersonation.

Reader Comments (31)


Posted by KEMI A on Oct 13 2009

I am so sorry for the death of this poor little girl due to whatevr reason. As a mother whose whose child will soon be off to a borading school, this are some of the issues that have been palguing my mind. Its time our our Ministry of education take more responsibility in what is offerred in this privet schools.

Posted by nanya alamah on Oct 13 2009

dis is rather sad,wats even sadder is the action of Faith Academy.

Posted by ADEDASOLA on Oct 13 2009

but the school said lets meet in court wr are they they are cowards

Posted by UWANA on Oct 13 2009

The truth of the matter is that it is not the fault of the school, it the fault of our health care system. Do we have health care in NIGERIA? I lost a close friend to the same calibre malaria and just last week a pretty lady at my bank died of this same malaria, when we all go for test they tell us is malaria and they will never mention the type of malaria. Its only when the person dies or it has eaten deep that’s when they say its cerebral malaria. I wonder what our doctors are doing. It’s only God that will save us in this country, because the doctor are just doing trails and errors with human lives. We are losing young, promising and intelligent people to wrong diagnose. When my friend was at intensive care unit at general hospital ikeja two men died of the same Celebral malaria, the families also complained same fault from doctors. I feel the doctors should be able to differentiate the type of malaria and give it the appropriate treatment.

Posted by lola on Oct 13 2009

wow..this gal' mother is actually my elder sis close friend.i knw how mch pain her mother has gone tru.am sure the reason for the parent' sue-in mst be,becos faith foundation has shown no remorse. i pray God that justice be given them(parents).amen

Posted by Adedasola Abdulmalik Balogun on Oct 13 2009

the way the school behave is bad , no delegation to the family , no rep in court , ios that all in the name of jesus @uwana leave that mater the school get payed for school fees and health care they should have the best doctor in nigeria , the pastor oyedepo have the best private jet , the money come fro wr ~ the members of the church , and the parents of the student abi

Posted by Emmanuel Majebi on Oct 13 2009

The type of dedication that schools used to have in our time is totally absent these days so taking your child to boarding school is a big gamble ... and as for me i hate gambling!! Esp with the most precious things in my life. Schools are nothing but money making machines these days. Thanks to the Conspiracy of gvt who have neglected our public schools we are at the mercy of all sorts of money making organisations disguising as schools. God help us!!

Posted by marymabel on Oct 13 2009

despite the problem of malaria in this country, the govt will never do anything to fight against it, rather they prefer wasting the country's money on things that are not important.May God touch our leaders to do the right thing.My sympathy to the family

Posted by Sherifah on Oct 13 2009

My judgement: 1. Arulogun's: My condolences 2. The principal:please resign...you are tooo insensitive. 3. The school and the church: Let us be more humanly in this case not defensive.

Posted by Muyiwa Akande, duduskee@yahoo.com on Oct 13 2009

If the school had been humble and responsible enough, I believe the parents wouldn't have dragged them to court. Even the Bible says that we should mourn with those that mourn but the arrogance of the school and its lawyer is un acceptable. I accept my condolences, the Aruloguns.

Posted by Jenom Likita on Oct 13 2009

this shows that these people involved are not serious about this case, From: Jenom Likita

Posted by TATA on Oct 13 2009

THIS IS MORE LIKE IT, GO TO COURT, SUE, EVEN IF IT TAKES 50 YEARS, EVEN IF YOU LOSE...THE SOCIETY WILL CHANGE

Posted by Allen O. on Oct 13 2009

Much as i commisserate with the family over the unfortunate loss of their Angel, i would implore that they let peace reign and leave everything to God. I would also suggest that they send a protest letter through a delegation to the presiding bishop of LFC and his wife not only because they their church runs the school, but because they are parents as well.

Posted by Anonymous on Oct 13 2009

@KEMI A, I cannot allow my kids to go to certain boarding schools in Nigeria. 80% of such schools did not think of emergency units or training their staffs for First Aid etc, but all they are after are the fees. Some kids are allergic to certain things or food and parents may not tell the school. As soon as a pupil is sick, apart from rushing the child to the hospital the parents should know immediately. Many schools prefer to wait until the child is dead... A child can die from simple malaria fever if not treated on time.

Posted by Abayomi on Oct 13 2009

@Allen O, you are wicked o... So if it happened to you, you would allow the school to go scot free. I beg shut your foul mouth. Some Nigerians are wicked o...

Posted by Mr. DOGOOD on Oct 13 2009

After the initial sabre-rattling and bragadoccio of "we will meet in court", it has dawned on the inhuman principal, uncaring church and their ignoramus of a lawyer that the case is a bad one. They may be contemplating out of court settlement hence the no-show at the court. Pls, Mr. Arulogun accept no of court settlement.

Posted by Another Allen on Oct 14 2009

I think the other Allen is such a stupid twat! When you pay such outlandish amount of money for secondary school education, what you expect is that at least the students be treated semi-decently, this is the failing of Faith Academy. Telling us your bishop also has kids is argumentum ad misericordiam - baseless and immature, I guess that's one of the reasons religious leaders find it easy to rip us all off. The family took the best course, the court of law as last recourse. Here the law hopefully will decide if the school acted right or not.

Posted by moi on Oct 14 2009

My heart goes out to the family who lost their daughter . Boarding schools are indeed great but issues such as health care is sometime that frightens me about Nigeria as a whole. I honestly feel there should be a better to settle this than a court case. I do from the little i know of celebral malaria that its something most doctors fail to diagose accurately ( most hospitals have very young doctors, all our consultants are all abroad largely due to the issues in the country) In this case i think we all need to comfort the family involved while not denying that the school should have been more vigilant with health care , i also know having almost lost a colleague to the same illness ( her saviour was she has a praticing consultant as a father ) , it was when her case detoriated actully that the father due to experience was able able to do a proper diagnosis . I do know LFC church upholds standards and I do beleive they are a good organisation. However , like they say words go a long way. I am surprised that LFC has not made any effort to contact this family and comfort them. However all I pray is that God would comfort this family and that he would bless you with more kids if you desire to have more and the sound of joy would once again fill your home.

Posted by sue on Oct 14 2009

well all i can say is it proves dat dis churches who open schs r more afta d mony than d upbring of d kids.yes a child is sick y dnt u contact d parents incase of any family issue u dnt knw.2nd, u r not jst a sch but a church sch wer is compassion?how did u let dis go as far as a court room?is dis wat d bible preaches?REVELATIONS.this is d 2nd ungodly act am hearin from this church, i tink the church shld sit bak n reborn its values cos they r not actin in d way of GOD cos weda pastor .... is concerned or not its his church n shld see dat no one dents its name.11yrs is no joke, 9months is no joke, labour is no joke.my heart goes to the mother.i wish d family my deepest condolence n pls fight dis course to d end our churches need to wake up to the cries of d pple not their pockets only.dnt leave anytin to God cos there r som acts we need to do on our own to correct injustice, evn the bible said knowck n d door shal b opened that means tak actions for ur prayers to com true.so cry, scream the church must wak up n do wats right so dis wont happen again.

Posted by femi on Oct 14 2009

I BLAME IT TO ALL THIS PARENTS DAT RUNS FROM ONE CHURCH TO ANODA.WHY NOT YOU ALL STICK UR ASS TO ONE CHURCH.NOW LOOK AT WAT A SO CALLED CHURCH HAS CAUSED TO UR FAMILY.DURING END TIME THE DEVIL WILL OPEN CHURCHES HERE AND THERE IN ODA TO SUCK INNOCENT BLOOD..PEOPLE IS TIME TO WAKE UP.

Posted by maureen on Oct 14 2009

MINISTRY OF EDUCATION SHOULD WAKE UP TO THEIR OBLIGATIONS,GOD WILL GIVE U THE FORTITUDE TO THE LOSS.JUSTICE MUST BE TO DONE,SO THAT IT WILL SERVE AS A DETERRENT TO OTHER SCHOOLS WHO ACTED AS IF THEIR ABOVE THE LAW.

Posted by Anonymous on Oct 14 2009

I pray that the God of heaven will forgive all of you that have nothing good to say to the church of God.....Who are you all to Judge? Do you all know that the bishop might not even be aware of this incident? How many things do you want him to be involved in? Who told you all he is the one in charge of running Faith Academy? I pray that God Himself will comfort the family for the loss. But guys...mind the comments you make concerning the church of God.

Posted by champagne on Oct 14 2009

my heart goes seriously to d family,but u all should watch ur mouth before u attract d wrath of God.dont say wat u dont know.may God console every one n sort everything out

Posted by Tunde Tabi on Oct 14 2009

Its only in Nigeria that we treat cases like this with levity.The fact that a missionary school is involved does not give them immunity from the law, well except there is another set of laws for churches . I think the Aruloguns should fight this to a logical end and God will definitely be on their side. Accept my condolences, Aru

Posted by shammah on Oct 15 2009

no,no, my sincere sympathy to the Arulogun's family. Cerebral malaria,cant be diagnosed jst lyk dt wen u r newly diagnosed of malaria,its a complication that comes wwhen the parasite gets to the brain and interfere with the blood supply dt wil also affect d oxygen supply in d brain n it comes with or without loss of conciousness,seizures n others, but i blame the school for not informing the parent that morenikeji was indisposed n on admission. Again,we r humans,oh the school n church shld av bn able to show sign of remorse to the family,at least most av children n they shld know how painful losing a member of d family can be. The family of Arulogun follow ur spirit.

Posted by muyiwa on Oct 15 2009

Students in Covenant university (where I attended) pay about 15,000 if I remember per year in Medical deposit, which translates to 100,000,000 plus since there are over 7,000 students. School fees is close to 400,000 and even more depending on course of study. The school never pays back deposits and routinely collects monies for different "charges", yet they cannot keep the students safe.

Posted by Dr. Tonye on Oct 17 2009

Please don't give up. The lord is ur strenght.I am interested in this matter and hope to meet u one day.Pls don't be shy to seek any form of assistance.The people are solidly behind you.

Posted by Gordy on Oct 18 2009

We are solidly behind you! The is also on your side! Faight the fight ...with faith!!!!

Posted by uli on Oct 25 2009

@allen, may it happen to you so you could leave it to God! I find it difficult to believe that the public relations people of that church has not read/heard about this case and consider it serious/damaging enough to bring to the bishop's attention. soft words melt the most hardened of hearts. I read about this death when it happened and so was surprised to read about it recently in the news - which simply goes to say someone did not do their homework very well. if a high-powered delegation from the school had gone to rub salve on this family's wound initiallly; this case would have died down by now. my mother says when a goat is bleating, it is simply asking for attention. yes, the parents know they cannot have her back but they want to prove a point because they have been pushed to the point of 'do whatever you like' by the school. those who say, separate the church from the school should better know that one is an extention of the other. if the church cares enough about her image, she should by now have given the school board a mandate to clear it's name or settle this issue. not showing up in court and now probably wanting an out-of-court settlement by not showing up in court is already late. it is high time we, especially believers realise that whereas the govt can do so many things and get away with it, society would not let the church/associates get away with even 0.40% of any of those things eg if a governor is caught in sexual harrassment or treasury-looting, people easily gloss over it [as par -what do you expect?] than when an ordinary usher is caught pilfering money or choirmaster sleeping with member. but then do we really blame them? even the bible sets extremely high standards for those who name the name of god by saying 'the judgement of those of you who are teachers would be more severe than non-teachers' those who also say do not talk about the church of God so as not to incur wrath, does the same bible that say 'judge not' not also say 'when ye gather together, judge yourselves and point out your wrongs one to another so that ye would not be judged by outsiders'?

Posted by ayforsure on Oct 27 2009

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

Posted by julia on Dec 15 2009

it is sad a little girl's life was lost. the fact is most of the people with school's in nigeria today have no business opening schools, they do so for monetary gain and yet a lot of parents send their kids there because of the ''name or prestige'' they think would come from saying my son or daughter attends this school.is the education great there? what of their health service? how about the meals served or protection of the children?? as long as these questions go unanswered and people dont care to find out about a school properly before sending their children there, these incidents will keep re-occuring because a man is the owner of a popular church doesnt mean he is liscenced to run a school, for what ''purpose'' exactly? this should be looked into........ much as it is such a sad situation, the motive for taking them to court is to do what exactly? 1. settle out of court? would the monetary settlement bring the girl back to life? 2. was she diagnosed with a kidney problem before being sent to boarding house and why did the parents not take her out of school immediately? or were they not informed by the school their daughter had taken ill? 3. were they in contact with their daughter and if so how did they not know she was ill enough for them to get her out rather than rely on the school for her care?? 4. the issue is that a lot of parents send their kids to boarding house for selfish reasons as i do not know what a child could learn more in boarding school that they cant learn as a day student! lets not get issues muddled up, who is responsible? the school as an entity or an individual? is it the board that is being sued or the people on duty the day it occured? bishop oyedepo and wife or the principal? sentiments should be put on a back burner and the matter criticaly analysed, name calling though would not sort the matter out, i pray God grants her eternal rest. her parents need to mourn her in peace rather than drag her name back and forth to court, why did they choose the school in the first place to send their daughter there? that question in itself would answer a lot of questions........



post a comment

Your name: *



* = Required information