Lead Image

IMHOTEP: The peoples'commonwealth

Print print Email email Share Share


I am writing this piece from the salubrious ambience of Marlborough House, headquarters of the Commonwealth Secretariat in London.

I was invited to participate in the civil society consultations preparatory to the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) that comes up in Trinidad in a matter of weeks.

The artworks adorning the walls are of Georgian England at its best, interspersed with the dour portraits of current Secretary-General Kamalesh Sharma and of former Secretaries-General, including our own Emeka Anyaoku, in his flowing robes and red cap as befit an Ndichie high chief.

This year’s theme, “Partnering for Sustainable Development” was the focus of much of our deliberations; with presentations from delegates from the Caribbean, Asia, the Pacific and Africa. Yours sincerely was the delegate for West and Central Africa.

Barring a few diplomatic fireworks from representatives of governments who were not happy that the searchlight was turned on their countries’ governance and human rights records, proceedings went in the decorous and civilised manner for which the Commonwealth has come to be known.

We all agreed that CHOGM 2009 is coming at a time of pressing challenges in international economic relations -- global financial meltdown,climate change and worsening poverty.

There was a sense of urgency on the imperatives of reengineering growth and restoration of global equilibrium. There is also the abiding challenge of tackling the HIV/AIDS global pandemic, especially legislation to curb discrimination and access to anti-retrovirals.

The delegate from Malta spoke passionately about the need for member countries to commit to the Commonwealth Gender Plan of Action that requires that 30 percent of all top decision-making positions in government be occupied by women, to an embarrassing murmur on the part of some of the men.

Issues of peace, conflict, governance and human rights featured prominently. Concerns were expressed about human rights violations in several countries.

Nigeria was among those that stood out, with the killings of journalists and the recurrent religious bloodbath for which we have become notorious.

A rather chilling report on The Gambia was submitted by the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI), where the President laid down an ominous warning to human rights groups: “If you think that you can collaborate with so-called human rights defenders, and get away with it...I will kill you, and nothing will come out of it.

"We are not going to condone people posing as human rights defenders to the detriment of the country.... Be rest assured that your security and personal safety would not be guaranteed by my Government.”

One would have thought we in West Africa have gone beyond this kind of language. Alas, not. The ultimate irony is that Banjul is the seat of the African Court of Human and Peoples’ Rights.

There was a lively debate on the role of culture, development and innovation led by Baroness Lola Young who is of Nigerian parentage and a member of the British House of Lords.

The Royal Commonwealth Society also threw the challenge for us to re-define the values and principles of the Commonwealth for the twenty-first century.

The fact that we are an association of free nations that works by consensus and has no binding legal force could be perceived as a key weakness.

But it could also be our strength. We were all anxious that the Commonwealth should not become an ineffectual ornamental club, but a forum for serious dialogue on some of the greatest challenges facing our 53 nations and 2 billion peoples.

I made the point that we need to move from being a Commonwealth of Nations to being a Commonwealth of Peoples.

I also made the point that no Commonwealth country has ever gone to war with another member state, and that we have always shared a heritage rooted in the common law tradition, in the civic virtues of tolerance and respect for human dignity.

Majority of delegates welcomed Rwanda’s application to join the Commonwealth. Dame Zena Daysh, a remarkable woman from New Zealand, spoke on the importance of building sustainable human ecologies that support the health and well being of all citizens -- about ethics, about responsibility and about solidarity.

Dame Zena is Founder and Executive Vice-Chair of the Commonwealth Human Ecology Council (CHEC). She later invited me for a walk through Trafalgar Square, where the pigeons of my youth have disappeared.

We talked about many things - about life, about the destiny of our nations and about the prospects of humanity in our new century.

She advised me to be courageous in adversity, to be strong and never to yield. “Don’t be afraid of pain, because you learn from it and it will go away after a while”.

Dame Zena speaks on authority. She is ninety-six years young and still going strong -- still active on so many good causes. She remains for me the enduring symbol of the Commonwealth of peoples.

Back
Dear reader.
While we value your feedback we have to moderate them, so your comments would appear in a maximum of one hour. Please feel free to return and read through again after another user may have replied to what you have said.
Please note that 234NEXT.com bears no responsibility for what readers post, and is not liable for any form of impersonation.

Reader Comments (6)


Posted by Kevin Nellies on Oct 26 2009

An interesting well written article. However just to query your point about Commonwealth members not going to war. Have not India and Pakistan fought at least 2 wars against each other?

Posted by Michael on Oct 26 2009

Dame Zena Daysh. She is truly remarkable and what a treasure she is to our planet.

Posted by Zoe Ware on Oct 26 2009

Obadiah - thanks for your very interesting article and reflections. The Royal Commonwealth Society would be very interested to hear from your readers about what they think about the future of the Commonwealth. You can join the Conversation online at www.thecommonwealthconversation.org

Posted by TATA on Oct 27 2009

the commonwealth is doomed ...no wealth is ever regarded as common especially when its commonality (owners) comes from insalubrious environment like the writer...

Posted by Obadiah on Oct 27 2009

Thanks so much Kevin, Michael, Zoe and Tata for your comments. I should have qualified my statement with regard to India and Pakistan. The RCS dialogue is very important.I will encourage people to participate. Tata, I respect your right to your opinion, but I beg to disagree when you say the Commonwealth is "doomed". On the contrary.

Posted by maja daruwala on Nov 18 2009

Dear Mr Mailafia: this is the director of the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative writing. I really liked your article. It captured the genteel politeness of Commonwealth meetings.But the hard realities are elsewhere. Illustratively, as a consequence of the Gambian President's 'killing statement' there was a huge outcry in Africa and a campaign in which - in terms of the Commonwealth - CHRI took the lead. We wrote to the outgoing chair Museveni and the host of the present chogm Manning in Trinidad and the Secretary General( happy to share on your site if you want them) to say dont invite this man to the meeting unless he makes a clear statement rescinding and gives reassurances of safety for human rights defenders. Two letters to the Secy Gen, information to the Ministerial Action Group that oversees Commonwealth compliance with its own founding principles and numerous articles in the press and a specific statement by a group of human rights defenders that met in London on the issue sent to all, has elicited not a word in reply. Not a peep of protest; not a public statement from the SG or the hosts or powerful colleagues like the Ugandan President or the Nigerians. Nothing! That is the Commonwealth in reality. You talk of a Commonwealth of peoples; CHRI has been advocating this for years. Go beyond the rhetoric of CHOGM. An examination of past communiques reads like a repetition of broken promises. We have long suggested that the chogm be made action oriented and effective. We suggested that the heads hold their meeting; civil society holds its meetings; and then there should be a joint statement which lays out a doable action plan for the Organisation in the in-between two years which is monitored and commented on in a peer review at the following CHOGM. We have asked for a special commissioner for human rights who can advise governments but is a specialist reporting to the secy gen; we have suggested that there should be a specific policy on human rights defenders articulated by the Commonwealth; we have asked that Commonwealth countries develop and make public national human rights action plans; we have asked that the Commonwealth lay down principles for police reform which will assure its people of a democratic police service not a regime oriented force. Most importantly for a people's Commonwealth we have strongly recommended that the Commonwealth vigorously promote the Right to in every member state. As assured access to information law -at the moment there are only 14 of 53 that have this - will ensure power to the people as almost nothing else can. None of our suggestions have even had a mention in the communiques; yet every expert report on which so much money is spent has advised nearly the same. If we dont have all this and we have instead a steady closing of spaces for right to associate, freedom of speech and expression, persisting criminal defamation laws, increasing anti terror laws, and little improvement in access to justice issues how do you envisage that a Commonwealth of People's will come about? The Commonwealth has a very long way to go but the proof of the pudding is in the eating. When there is silence on so fundamental an issue as protecting the lives of citizens from the clear articulation of intentions by a head of state we have to draw the conclusion that is no evidence that the Commonwealth believes in its own values and words. This is what is so saddening for 1.6 million people most of whom are poor and powerless. sincerely, Maja Daruwala



post a comment

Your name: *



* = Required information