Lead Image

Many were disappointed when no winner emerged for the coveted literary prize. Photo: NEXT

There is no winner for premier literary prize

Print print Email email Share Share


Out of 161 entries, no winner emerged for the 2009 NLNG Literature Prize at the Grand Awards Night held on Saturday evening in Abuja.

There were gasps of shock and surprise from people inside the Congress Hall of the Transcorp Hilton Hotel, venue of the ceremony, as Ayo Banjo, spokesperson for the panel of judges for the literature prize, declared that none of the works merits the award.

Nine works of poetry had earlier been announced for the prize. ‘Litany’ by Omo Uwaifo, ‘Love Apart’ by Hyginus Ekwuazi, ‘Songs of Odamolugbe’ by Ademola Dasylva, ‘Eaters of the Living’ by Musa Idris Okpanachi and ‘From a Poem to its Creator’ by Diego Okenyodo were some of the nominated works.

The others were Nengi Ilagha’s ‘January Gestures’, G’Ebinyo Ogbowei’s ‘Song of a Dying River’, Ahmed Maiwada’s ‘Fossils’ and ‘A Memory of Rivers’ by Lindsay Barrett.

The judges’ verdict was that none of the works, despite the fact that three of them had previously won poetry prizes, was good enough to be awarded the prize.

This is the second time the Literature Prize would not be awarded. During the inaugural edition of the prize which incidentally held in Abuja in 2004, the judges decided against awarding the prize because of the poor quality of the three shortlisted works they said arose from self-publishing.

‘Condolences,’ by Bina Nengi-Ilagha, ‘Fattening House,’ by Omo Uwaifo and ‘House of Symbols,’ by Akachi Adimora-Ezeigbo, were the works shortlisted then.

The common man as star

It wasn’t a total loss for literature, however, as Chima Ibeneche, Managing Director, the NLNG, stated that the prize money of $50,000 will be given to the Nigerian Academy of Letters to develop literature in Nigeria. He said the organisers are committed to maintaining absolute standards for the award and would thus abide with the decision of the judges.

It was a different case for the Science Prize as Andrew Jonathan Nok, a biochemistry teacher at the Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, got the prize for his works on trypanosome (sleeping sickness) parasites.

Earlier, Mr. Ibeneche reiterated the objective of the prizes. He said the NLNG “promote science and literature to give others the same opportunity you gave us; to give writers and scientists a shot at success; to give writers and scientists who have more or less operated at the margins of our society, the pleasure to sit with full merit amongst the business and political elite and be able to spread their fragrance of joy and wisdom in this struggling nation of ours”.

He added: “I have yet another reason for this big party. To have an event where politicians are spectators, and the ordinary person, the star!”

You are failures

In an extemporaneous keynote he delivered, sitting obviously because of old age, (he was assisted to the stage by an aide and an official of the NLNG), Emeka Odimegwu Ojukwu, former Biafran leader and chairman of the All Progressives Grand Alliance (APGA), underscored the importance of cooperation and unity. He commended the cooperation between the NLNG and Nigeria which he noted is yielding positive dividends for the country. He noted that although two owners emerge from cooperation, the venture remains the property of the owner. Mr. Ojukwu added that partnering with another person doesn’t change one’s status as the owner but pointed out that, “Whatever you do, the ultimate owner is God”.

Mr. Ojukwu also alluded to the crisis in the country’s educational sector. “Don’t ever allow our educational institutions to drop behind. You can’t tell me you love Nigeria when the universities are shut down for months. My friends are ministers but I say to you, you failed on this one,” he said, adding that a good Nigerian is an educated Nigerian.

“He knows the country, its history and what links its people together. Open the door (of your brain) wide and let knowledge fill it”.

On unity, Ojukwu said: “Ethnic jingoism is a thing of the past. We are Nigerians. Nothing more. Work hard, be true to your neighbour.”

Back
Dear Reader.
While we value your feedback we may block inappropriate comment. Please feel free to respond to new comments. Note also that 234NEXT bears no responsibility for what readers post and is not liable for any form of impersonation.

Reader Comments (30)


Posted by George on Oct 12 2009

I believe is its not a bad outing if nobody wins the prize.Stanadard must be maintained and merit the hallmark of the literary integrity.

Posted by Ayoka on Oct 12 2009

Something smells real funky here. If the books were good enought to be shortlisted, then one of them was good enough to win a prize. Even PDP with its plethora of candidates in Anambra still managed to pick one candidate. NLNG should direct its CSR elsewhere, if this is the kind of mago-mago it wants to indulge in.

Posted by Salau O John on Oct 12 2009

So far so good, I believe this is better in a way as the truth of the matter is that none of the contestants' works falls into the theme of the piece that was warranted for winning the premier prize. It's all good....

Posted by Phil on Oct 12 2009

How is this prize funded and where does the money go if it is not awarded?

Posted by Tade Ipadeola on Oct 12 2009

@Phil: We are learning that this prizemoney just went to the 'judges'.

Posted by too on Oct 12 2009

50, 000 dollars is no small money. if the judges do not think any of the works qualitative enough to win the prize, then ok with it. i for one is not satisfied with a previous winner of the prize - so much being given for so little. inasmuch as we try to encourage writers, we should also encourage them to produce works that can compete convincly anywhere in the globe. maybe, when it is denied for the next two sessions better works can really come up.

Posted by Caesar on Oct 12 2009

So sad. Anyway, it tells clearly that the judges would like poetry to still remain poetry. No desperate moves!

Posted by ogunniyi Samuel on Oct 12 2009

This is absolute Madness! They said none of them was good enough to win the prize- my question 'why nominating them in the first place'? To worsen the case, the prizes when to the organisers!!! Reaping where they did not sow. Never knew 'PDP' is everywhere!

Posted by Oluwa toyin Adisa on Oct 12 2009

Winner Actually emerged! The Wnner ISsssss INTERGRITY !!! I congratualte the organisers, the judges and the sponsors for sowering where Nigeria is falling; for upholding the standard when it was not palatable to do so. In a meritorious competition; the case is not who comes first but who got the expected score! There can be no half pregnance. It is either there or not. A greater challenge has been thrown to the competitors to go back to the drawing board, work harder and get more motivated. This is clearer interpretation of givein Obama, a less than one year in the throne of Presidency, who became President two weeks to the closure of the nomimations; whose efforts at institutionalising World Peace is yet to have significant impacts. He was given the noble peace award by the coward panel of judges who could not say no body won the award due to increasing failure of the the world stakeholders to make the world a peaceful place to live in.

Posted by Oga on Oct 12 2009

Please refer to Ojumba by one of his titles, either use "Dim" or "Ikemba"; don't call him Mr. Ok?

Posted by Tade Ipadeola on Oct 12 2009

Pleeeeeeeeeeeeease! In which part of the world do judges award contested money to themselves?

Posted by Mimi speakeasy on Oct 12 2009

If this is the case, i think the judges should then apologise to the body of Nigerian literature for awarding the prize to Agary's Yellow-Yellow(2008) because that was bestowing mediocrity on us!

Posted by Aluta on Oct 12 2009

Akachi Adimora-Ezeigbo is a university lecturer so how did her book suffer from errors last year? Is she not a Professor of English at UNILAG? They just don't want to part with the prize money last year and this year. No matter what a writer must win... The award should be stopped by the Federal Government in that case. Is there a competition commission in Nigeria to regulate all these nonsense? Expensive sh*t! If any of these writers wins a foreign or alternative prize then they should sue NLNG for about 5 million dollars.

Posted by Tim on Oct 12 2009

WRITERS SHOULD BOYCOTT THE COMPETITION.

Posted by Awaal Gata on Oct 12 2009

What a shame! the followers of government have done it again, killing the country's cretivities. i know that the prize was not given because most of nigerian poets are ainti-government.

Posted by Jolly-dey-go on Oct 12 2009

@Awaal Gata, na so? I am sorry for Nigerian Poets! Can you imagine what would happen if the Nobel Prize committee says no writer was worth a literary prize? I wonder what Baba Soyinka has to say to this... Nigeria is doomed!

Posted by ego on Oct 12 2009

too painful for words. shame on these guys. greed greed greed they seek ye, integrity they have not. shame shame shame, nigeria yet again stumbles at the feet of integrity. The curses of the gods keep raining... how do we appease them? those angry gods that is

Posted by Tade Ipadeola on Oct 13 2009

First things first, let the members of the NLNG jury tell us precisely what their relationships are with the Nigerian Academ of Letters. Then we can proceed...

Posted by The Dragon on Oct 13 2009

...I wonder what many of this forum's contributors would have said if the literary prize was awarded and the winner now fails in International competition.It would have been the same old story that the jury has been compromised. Sometimes it is good to follow reason and not passion.In my opinion,l believe there are still many people of integrity in this country and think that the action of the jurists is in line because if you don't stand for something,you're bound to fall for everything. They have stood for integrity and world class reasoning. Let the critics organize same and see if they can do better. If they(critics) believe that one of the write ups is good enough to win the prize,let them analyse the shortlisted entries and enlighten us on how they arrive at their decision.Then their criticism would have been justified. Like someone said,getting the highest mark doesn't mean you cross the cut off mark. God bless Nigeria.

Posted by Bose on Oct 13 2009

@Dragon. What the hell are you on about. The whole point of a shortlist is that they have assessed the poems and decided that out of the 191 submissions, these nine are the ones worthy of the award. In literature award, you cannot have a shortlist and not award. For you not to award, it means the decision of the judges themselves is faulty. Not awarding shortlist is not a show of integrity, it shows that those involved do not understand the meaning of shortlist as it pertains to literature. If they had said from the longlist there were none worthy, then no one can argue with them. But when you shortlist, it means that you have decided that those shortlisted are worthy and therefore, you must award. As usual, Nigerian is yet a laughing stock of the world.

Posted by Ayobami on Oct 13 2009

What the hell is the Nigerian Academy of letter? What the hell is that?

Posted by Ayobami on Oct 13 2009

What the hell is the Nigerian academy of letters? Where have they being since literature and writers have been sufferheading in Nigeria? And what on earth are they going to do with the money? What initiatives do they have that the money will help them with? From what I know, these guys are about academics, scholarship for fellows academic journals and the like. While that is all good, how does that help creative writing in Nigeria? And yes like Tade said, what is the relationship between the judges and this academy?

Posted by doyin on Oct 13 2009

this is ridiculous... I believe the books were shortlisted in the first place. Why shortlist books when you don't plan to award anyone the prize.. Nonsense.

Posted by Debola K on Oct 14 2009

Sort of different congratulations - to the academy of letters, reaping where they didnt sow, to the nlng for fooling all the people all the time, and to all the poets who appeared in the late night show. shame shame

Posted by Tade Ipadeola on Oct 14 2009

This is why literature matters. It always paints the true picture of any society.

Posted by Kolawole Ajao on Oct 17 2009

"Who has custody of the custodians?Who polices the police?" I have always maintained the fact that creative writers shouldn't rely on wanting to win awards.I have never submitted anything for an award.What happens when those called up to weigh and examine art works are themselves below the judging line? This panel of judges has simply shown it is not qualified to have been instituted.What we are saying is LET US KNOW THE BEST AMONG THE WORKS PRESENTED!

Posted by Simnom on Oct 21 2009

While I'm not a title freak, I believe it's absolutely appropriate to give honour to whom it is due. It felt so odd in my mouth when I read "Mr. Ojukwu". Is this some other Ojukwu, or the Ikemba himself? Some of his comments sounded truly Nigerian.

Posted by Jerry on Oct 22 2009

It;s a slap on the Nigerian literature. What are you talking about academy of letters? who knows them and what have they done for literature to deserve $50,000 which they awarded themselves. Writers should boycott this prize.

Posted by Nd Ogbuzulu on Oct 25 2009

@Bose and Doyin. Don't be fooled. Producing a short list does not mean a prize must be awarded. It means a few have been selected for re-examination to determine whether they meet the criteria. Remember that the judges report was presented by Prof Ayo Banjo, a former Vice Chancellor of University of Ibadan. We all know his clout in Nigeria and Nigerian literature and I want to assume that other judges may be of similar stature. Does any one dare question whether the judges are up to it because some of the writers are university teachers? Why on earth do we assume that all pass marks must be excellent? We should have read the hand writings in the wall. The nine short lists just got pass, not very good, not excellent. If some got very good, they indeed would have been isolated and elevated. Period. I'm indeed disappointed that most Nigerians most shamelessly stand for mediocrity.This award has been variously been defined as African's own Nobel prize and I wonder why many people think that it can be won by a few bad verses. This must be a dream! I can only say kudos to the judges for not awarding the prize to any 'gunner', just to play to the gallery. And more so to Nigeria LNG for being a leading light at this our time of darkness. By upholding the judges decision not to award the prize to a 'non-sequitur'and going ahead to donate the prize money for development of literature, the company has shown it is truly out to make a difference in it's pursuit for excellence. I urge the company to ignore stupid utterances by never do wells who see the prize as free money for the boys- even when they did not work for it. For those calling for a boy-cot, pray that the organisers of the prize do not read your comments. Otherwise they will 'boy-cot' you first from submitting any work. In any case, I doubt if any of you can write even a short essay.

Posted by Martin on Oct 30 2009

I am gobsmacked at such a verdict. If tis wz so blunt who den is worth d prize? Nigerian authors en poets lotta work has to be done from every viewing point.



post a comment

Your name: *



* = Required information